Ignorance of PTSD is a plague against veterans

by
Chaplain Kathie

With literally hundreds of articles to read during the week, I tend to pass by opinion pieces. There is just not enough hours in the day to respond to all of them. This one got to me. Maybe I'm in a bad mood this morning? Lack of sleep tends to do that.


A broken warrior By Catherine Whitney was as great piece telling the story of her brother, a Vietnam veteran wounded by PTSD. This lead to a response from a reader denying the reality of PTSD. While I've read too many of this kind of ignorance from the uneducated over the years, there is no excuse for them to attack the veterans they are claiming they care about. What is behind the denial of PTSD and baseless claims? The end result is that this kind of attitude is like a plague against veterans and the generations of warriors risking their lives, putting themselves in harms way and suffering for doing what the rest of us have not.

Here is the comment posted on Hutchinson News Online and my reply in case they will not allow it to be published.

The PTSD myth
Catherine Whitney's "Broken Warrior" piece about veterans and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder was about 180 degrees off course. It perpetuates the myth that there is an epidemic of mental illness in veterans because of their military experiences. My 30 years in the VA disability benefit bureaucracy showed a far different situation. Almost every VA employee I ever met who evaluated PTSD claims concluded that most were bogus grabs for money.

The truth is that the VA pays out billions of dollars a year in payments for PTSD where it does not exist. A huge self-serving industry has sprung up around this "disorder." Veterans profit by claiming the condition when they don't have it. VA medical clinicians diagnose the condition because their jobs depend on it. There is also profit for the attorneys, service organization representatives, VA bureaucratic personnel, politicians, and, yes, even authors who grandstand on this. The result is a siphoning of money away from the truly deserving vets with the real injuries and wounds.

Catherine Whitney would have you believe that it is difficult for a veteran to receive a diagnosis and money for PTSD. Actually, the money and diagnosis are available to about every vet, with or without a combat history. There is no objective test for the condition. It exists if the vet seeking money says he has it and the VA clinician needing a job supports him. The VA tends to pay more PTSD money to the rear echelon clerks than to vets with primary combat duties. That the money is paid inversely to actual combat experience is just a clue to the enormity of the fraud and abuse surrounding this diagnosis.

Ms. Whitney blamed her brother's alcoholism and situation in life to his military experiences rather than face the fact that some people just become alcoholics. She said that today's war heroes too often become tomorrow's poor or resort to suicide when there is no statistical evidence of that. Such unsupported claims were exposed years ago by the book "Stolen Valor" by B.G Burkett. Anyone who wants a true picture of the PTSD situation should go find a copy. What you shouldn't do is listen to people like Catherine Whitney or anyone trying to make a buck from the true sacrifices of vets.

MARK ROGERS

Pretty Prairie

http://www.hutchnews.com/Westernfront/wfrogers

Mr. Rogers,
What is your history with researching PTSD, living with it or even knowing someone with it? How many veterans have you talked to so wounded they have to struggle just to find reasons to get up out of bed after another night of reliving what they went thru in their dreams? Have you ever seen a veteran going thru a flashback? Somehow, I doubt you know very much about this but apparently think you can justify your lack of knowledge and ambivalence by writing about it.

Here are some facts for you because apparently while you have an opinion, it is not based on facts but merely assumptions.

PTSD comes from an outside force after a traumatic event that is captured within the soul/emotions, in case you are not a religious person. Scientists have found the part of the brain changed by PTSD responsible for the emotions in humans. It's been proven.

Next, if you ever read history regarding warfare, you'd see all the signs of it. Ancient Greek and Romans recorded the aftermath of war. It is recorded in the pages of the Bible even though there is a tendency to over look it. Abraham was a warrior and so was Moses. Read Judges and Kings or the Psalms of David and see it. Every generation of Americans have endured this invisible wound going back to the Revolutionary War. It's been called many things. Nostalgia, Soldier's Heart, Shell Shock and then arriving at Post Traumatic Stress Disorder by 1978. By then there were 500,000 Vietnam veterans with PTSD and this was published in several studies. The DAV commissioned a study by Jim Goodwin, Psy.D, Readjustment Problems Among Vietnam Veterans, The Etiology of Combat Related Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and it was all there.

By 1986 there were 117,000 suicides. Two later studies put the numbers between 150,000 and 200,000. Over 300,000 ended up homeless. Incarcerations of Vietnam veterans suffering from PTSD and self medicating with street drugs and alcohol became part of the aftermath. One more fact you lack is that had it not been for Vietnam veterans coming back and fighting to have this wound treated as a service connected disability, the rest of us would find no help at all. That includes police officers, firefighters and emergency responders. It includes people suffering from traumatic events like crimes and accidents along with natural disasters. All generations of veterans have been helped because of what Vietnam veterans did.

Now, you can look at PTSD anyway you want, but when you publicly come out making baseless claims against the reality, you are a plague much like the morons in the past unable to think like a human with emotions. People like you are part of the reason my own husband would not go for help when PTSD was mild and he had a better chance to heal more fully. Because of people like you he didn't want help until it was almost too late. I had the ammunition to overrule people like you because I knew exactly what PTSD was and what it was doing to him along with all the other veterans I had helped thru the years.

Next time you go to the VA try talking to a Marine back from Iraq, if they'll talk to you at all. I'm a Chaplain so they know they can trust me. I've held enough of them in my arms when they were crying and apologizing for the pain they were carrying because people like you would rather judge them than help them heal. No one is slamming veterans because they have PTSD, but people like you slam them and insult them all the time because you deny this wound is real. These brave men and women ended up doing their duty, finishing their mission, caring for their brothers in arms with the pain eating away at them with flashbacks and nightmares and did not allow themselves to think of themselves until their duty was over. And you, you with your ignorance insult them?

And now read what produced the comment by Mr. Rogers.

A broken warrior
By Catherine Whitney - Special to the Los Angeles Times

My brother, Jim, was a soldier once, but when he died, at age 53, he was long past the time when anyone called him a hero. He died alone, in poverty, alienated from family and friends, his life and death complicated by war wounds that penetrated far deeper than the pieces of shrapnel that won him his Purple Heart. Jim was a Vietnam combat engineer who survived the war but later became another kind of statistic - a lost soul, a veteran who never recovered from his experiences.

Jim didn't seek help, nor did the Army offer it during his 20-year military career. Instead, to try to deal with his pain, he began to drink. He was forced into retirement when he was 37, with nothing but a drawer full of medals, a subsistence-level pension and a crushed spirit.

We hear a lot of talk about post-traumatic stress disorder afflicting troops and veterans. To its credit, the military has tried to update its attitudes and systems to accommodate the growing number of traumatized soldiers returning from our current wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. But PTSD is still viewed as an abnormal response to battlefield trauma rather than the reaction of a normal person to the horrors of war. And so the stigma remains.

Tragically, it is often left to individual soldiers and veterans to seek help. Many are career military, as my brother was, and they fear the dishonor associated with a diagnosis of PTSD.
go here for more
http://www.hutchnews.com/Columns/brokenmkow

When you live with PTSD in your own home, you know what is real. When you help other veterans and police officers, firefighters and their families, you know what is real. When you work with Iraq and Afghanistan veterans, you know what is real. People like Mr. Rogers, well, they are part of the reason the stigma lives on and I really believe they are the biggest insult to veterans because they seem to think they are looking for a free ride. I don't know about this Mr. Rogers or his history but he fails to understand that this kind of suffering is real, they can make a lot more money working for a living instead of being unable to work and collecting disability from the VA and suffer all kinds of indignation in the process. If people like Mr. Rogers cared at all about our veterans, he would invest some time in finding out what PTSD is, what it does to them instead of spending time attacking them. He is too much like too many still in some kind of bubble finding fault with the wounded instead of themselves getting in the way of them getting the help to heal. The dishonor only exists because of people like Mr. Rogers and frankly I'm glad he does not live in my neighborhood!